Its not 3 bad results, to quote Michael Grant in from the other thread "For the last three seasons their every cup exit has been dismal: Queen's Park, Hibs (by 4-1), Dundee United (4-1 again), Queen of the South (4-3), Kilmarnock (4-2) and now Dunfermline." The collapse against Utd was pitiful and the hibs game has to be hight of Calderwoods tactical ineptitude ever witnessed.
How can you look at his cup record with us and think somone else could not do better?
This was our year, easy as fuck draw and he couldn't even make the Semi-final.