Think it is perfectly valid to be critical of the scouting and player recruitment. The last few seasons havent been overwhelmingly successful. Mcinnes has admitted that himself, he also stated they need to cast the net further afield.
I think we are being priced out of the English Leagues particularly where transfer fees are involved. That being said I think signs are positive given what he has delivered so far, glaring gaps aside.
cosgrove isnt going to score goals.. ferguson looked ok we need footballers in cm so for me should be gleeson ball and or ferguson forrester, shinnie should be lb but tell you what devlin mckenna v good
Think Mcinnes performance in transfer market has been ropey. I think Hibs have recruited pretty well, Mcginn, Mcgeouch, Boyle , interesting to see how they get on this year