I've never really paid any attention to what the critics say and personally disagree with several posts on this one but its down to personal opinion in the end.
However one band really does stick out for me in terms of the what i consider to have been completely undeserved hype........Travis!
I first saw them at TITP 1998 and prior to that I'd only heard a couple of songs on compilations albums but they seemed to be a half decent, fun, indie rock band with tunes you could get a decent bounce to especially on a slightly boozy sunny afternoon in perthshire
U16 Girls, Tied to the 90s, Happy etc.
Then came 'The Man Who' which for me made Leonard Cohen and Radiohead seem full of Joy.
Worse for me was how they suddenly went from afternoon main stage warm up to Main Headliners with lots of teary eyed pre-pubescent girls singing along.
I often hear folk complaining of bands with songs that all sound the same but too often I found myself in the minority when I put Travis into that camp.