For sure, it's a tough one. Hebrew is spot on, they are a massive club by comparison but then again so are Barnsley and he turned them down flat. He has a real affection for the place, is very settled and, as you say, has it all going well at ICT (though I would add the disclaimer that ICT are not as well run as the public perception) so why go? I wasn't surprised that he dinghied Barnsley, even posted on here that I thought he would. I suspect that butcher really loves Scottish football, pretty much all his top moments as player (club anyway) and manager came here. I think the Hibs job may just turn his head a little, he's 54 now too so it may cross his mind that he might not get many such offers again, would I be right in saying he's now the oldest manager in the league come to think of it?
Thing is I cant help but think that Butcher has found his level a wee bit at ICT, if he goes I would find it very interesting to see if he was able to replicate his success. Malpas would have to go to, from what I hear he is the brains of the outfit and butcher is the motivator.