Wow. Where to start on this thread. Well i suppose a good place to start would be an observation on how the topic of Mr James Calderwood is still capable of inspiring such focused debate by aberdeen fans over two years after he left the club.
I've made my opinion of JC clear on this forum on more than one occasion. Put simply i think he generally did pretty well, signed some good players and produced a solid if fairly uninspiring team that underachieved on a number of significant occasions. He talked an awful lot of shite in the media which a lot of aberdeen fans found embarrassing and did him no favours when results became poorer. He clearly had his undroppable favourites (byrne mackie etc) and his tactical choices were questionable on more than one occasion. He was initially backed well by the board but things went sour when they didnt back him in the transfer window after the copenhagen game.
I maintain this was where things went wrong for him, keeping hart and clark and adding a couple of players at this point would have pushed us on to bigger and better for the rest of that season and the next. Things started to stagnate and then with the likes of nicholson leaving to be replaced by casper we went into decline. Unfortunately Calderwood was nowhere near a good enough coach or tactician to compensate for the drop in standard of player. I see comparisons with harry redknapp as he's also fine as long as he has money to spend and clearly enjoys close relations with his players. Its no secret that Joe Jordan is the brains of that operation though, a role Jimmy Nichol played at Aberdeen (theres a guy i would have back at the club in a coaching role in a second).
I've mentioned before that a good pal of mine works at county, i asked him about Calderwood a few months after he got there. The report i got back was quite condemning. Familiar phrases of players starting regardless of performance and odd tactical choices were noticable. This was added along with a general treating of contempt of non playing staff and most disturbingly the best left back at the club, Scott Morrison, was dropped because "he was born with a silver spoon in his mouth". In short my pal, who is friendly, amiable and generally finds a good word to say about most, text me when he left saying "thank fuck that fat fucking orange cunt has left" I found this very telling.