I don't understand that reasoning, what are you basing it on?
I think this is the 11 that JC will start with if everyone's available to him.
Langfield
Foster - Diamond - Severin - Mulgrew
Smith - Kerr - McDonald - Aluko
Mackie - Miller
However, I'd quite like to see us play a 4-5-1, now that we've got two good wide players and a couple of good sitting players, just to see how we get on.
Langfield
Foster - Diamond - Considine - Mulgrew
Kerr - Seve
Smith - McDonald - Aluko
Miller
Only problem with this formation is that we're relying heavily on the 11 that are starting, as they're all ideal for the position they'd play in. A 4-4-2 enables us to chop and change players with very little difference.