Held off from commenting on this thread for a while. Wanted to have a proper think of what has annoyed me this season. If we thought last summer was a big one, this one is huge. DM hasn't shown he's got the knowledge or creativity to do what is needed. There are so many holes across the board that now need to be filled that it almost makes it impossible to maintain the level we've been used to. Of course it remains to be seen if he'll be here next season too.
We need another forward, that most certainly is not Wilson. We need two central midfielders (creative and enforcer that shinnie has been doing) and at least one winger. I'd like to see Lowe re-sign (obviously, on loan or permanently) and get another RB. Logan has been unreliable at best over the past couple of seasons. Love him as a player and a character, but really don't know if his hearts in it anymore. Not sure if we'll see McKenna go this summer, he's hardly set the heather alight since Jan. A lot of basic errors, which are probably down to inexperience. There's talent there, but I think we'd be extremely lucky to see £5m for him.
I agree with KNS, got to be a no to Hoban. No doubting his ability but we really can't afford to have someone who is made of glass. Costs us a fortune.
If Shinnie does go to Derby, I wish him well. We'll miss his drive and passion massively next season. I'd much rather he go there than anywhere else in Scotland. He's better than Wigan.
Still not sure if I have confidence in DM to do what's necessary. Time will tell I guess.