sorry, is this thread solely for my purpose...?
"Walk into" is a step too far. If everyone was fit, Diamond included, then I honestly don't think he would. Diamond is a better player than Irvine. Ifil does similar things to Irvine like kick the ball out of play when there is no need, incapable of finding a team mate ten yards away, lunges into silly tackles he doesn't have to make. Considine also does similar things to Irvine, mainly huge losses of concentration.
I've said it a hundred times, I know it's not going to be a popular opinion but I just did not rate the guy. Scratching my eyes out with cats claws was preferrable to watching him play for us. People liked him because he was a "nice guy" and cos he kissed the badge. He was largely a poor player. He had his moments, of course and the penalty in the cup final will live with me til the day I die but look at the bigger picture. He had McLeish holding his hand for the first few years of him being in the team on a regular basis and he was pretty ropey then. Big Eck left and it went from bad to worse. You obviously rate the guy and good on ye, but I don't, maybe you should just accept that.
And, incidentally, there is not a chance in hell he was a better player than Anderson.