Signing players - Miller can only sign players that Calderwood WANTS. He can only sign players that Calderwood wants and are also attainable within the limits of the budget set out by the board.
We've attracted players of a good standard (relative to Scottish terms) in guys like Severin, Smith, Nicholson and Whelan. How much of that is down to Miller? do you know? Because I don't.
I also don't know of any players who haven't signed because of Miller. There may well be dozens, but there may be none. I don't know. and neither do you.
He's pushing for a new training ground, that's a positive thing.
He's revamped the youth set up, which is also a positive thing but we won't see the results of that for another couple of years at least.
All in, I don't understand why he gets so much criticism. Yours certainly appears partly based on not liking the guy as a person. I would say I'm reasonably happy with him there, if only because he's a better figurehead for the club than Milne. But, it's potentially a Catch 22 position, we may well not know how good Miller is for us until he's gone, and then it may be too late.