Soutar fears for Hampden place

[mizer]

Aberdeen keeper Derek Soutar fears his latest error could wreck his Hampden dream. His blunder led to a Falkirk equaliser in Mondays SPL clash. Now Soutar is praying boss Jimmy Calderwood will not drop him for the semi final clash.

 

He did fuck up but in my opinion is far more reliable than clangers. Soutar to start!

[Kowalski]

Winters.

[mizer]

Winters.

 

  :rofl:I had thought of adding that option......in fact I will

[OrlandoDon]

Leighton or John 'Budgie' Burridge.

[mizer]

Quite worring that more people would rather have winter in goal than Langfield.......but I'm not surprised.

[quirie]

I said winters for a joke

 

Its got to be Soapy even with that mistake against falkirk

[capitalsharpie]

Yet again its all about creating a sense of stability in the back line. Chopping and changing keepers every game is bad news. It has to be Soapy. If our defence is poor, keepers no matter who they are will always be forced into mistakes.

[mizer]

Anyone want to own up to voting Langfield? Reasons?

[mizer]

but think Langfield is possibly more of a big game keeper

 

What was his last big game? Oh aye the semi at Tynecastle against the arabs - he played well that night! 

[Mackie's ace!]

What was his last big game? Oh aye the semi at Tynecastle against the arabs - he played well that night! 

 

At home v Bayern?

[tlg1903]

I'd go soutar for this one as i dont think he's done anything to warrant being dropped.  Mind you he didnt the last time either but JC was right to make the change given clangers performance against dnipro.  When it comes down to it i reckon clangers is a better shot stopper than Soutar, can see him playing in the final providing we dont fuck up on sat.  Personally its not a decision i envy calderwood having to make.

[Kowalski]

Langfield is possibly more of a big game keeper

 

[Guest Caroline B]

He's got to stick with Souter for this one. All in all apart form his wee blunder against Falkirk, he hasn't done too many things wrong. One mistake shouldn't be held against him. Time will tell.

 

I'm all for bringing in a new keeper anyway in the summer. We need someone who can help organise the back lot into conceding less goals.

[vanderark14]

Bobby Mimms

[Guest Caroline B]

Tubby Ogston

[caledonia]

Souter for me although i agree he is the best of a bad lot..

[Reekie_Red]

Haha! I had to vote Winters. I'll never forget his save against Kanchelskis. Priceless!

 

I mind watching that final in a pub in Edinburgh. Some innocent bystander happened to wander in half way through the match and said "who's that shite in goals for Aberdeen?"

 

I turned around and said "Robbie Winters"

 

He said "Robbie Winters? The striker?!"

 

At that point, he started cheering for Aberdeen.

[SWA]

I hate when an outfield player goes in goal and everyone cheers when they make a save, like it's the best save ever, regardless of how shite it actually was. 

[El Padre™]

I hate when an outfield player goes in goal and everyone cheers when they make a save, like it's the best save ever, regardless of how shite it actually was. 

 

Why?

[BigAl]

Got to be Soapy, might of fucked up on Monday night, but had probably kept us in the game prior to his foxs paw

[SWA]

Why?

 

It's just stoopit!  If it's a genuinely good save, fairy nuff, but it's usually nae and folks just mak the maist o it because it's an ootfield player.

[phil-stellaartois-mcguire]

I hate when an outfield player goes in goal and everyone cheers when they make a save, like it's the best save ever, regardless of how shite it actually was.   

 

that save reekie mentions was an absolute BLINDER.  I would have cheered that if leighton or snelders made it.  Going by the fact a "striker" made the save made it all the better.

[quirie]

Jimmy said in the EE today that Soapy is in goal and doesnt know why he thought he might of been dropped

[El Padre™]

It's just stoopit!  If it's a genuinely good save, fairy nuff, but it's usually nae and folks just mak the maist o it because it's an ootfield player.

 

Any save is a good save for an outfield player who suddenly finds himself in goals. Robbie showed a lot of guts to do what he did that day as does any player in that situation, they deserve a cheer for every save they make.

[SWA]

that save reekie mentions was an absolute BLINDER.  I would have cheered that if leighton or snelders made it.  Going by the fact a "striker" made the save made it all the better.

 

I wiznae referrin to that save in particular, just talkin in general min