Jump to content

Sunday 29 December - kick-off 5.15pm

Scottish Premiership - Dundee Utd v Aberdeen

Recommended Posts

Posted

The top two deserved to go through, the rest deserved nothing.

 

But it clearly states the first 3 earn the right to go through to the next round, we finished third so deserved to go through.

 

The structure of the UEFA cup is not the issue as that is a different argument.

Posted

But it clearly states the first 3 earn the right to go through to the next round, we finished third so deserved to go through.

 

The structure of the UEFA cup is not the issue as that is a different argument.

 

Its part of the argument. If you can go through when you only win 1 game, lose 2 and draw 1 then its clear that the systems got problems, which is how we managed to get through.

Posted

1 win in 8 games in the whole tournament says otherwise. We benefited from a stupid set-up, thats all.

 

Aye, a league system with 3 points for a win, 1 point for a draw and 0 points for a loss is something I've always thought was silly.  ???

Posted

Aye, a league system with 3 points for a win, 1 point for a draw and 0 points for a loss is something I've always thought was silly.  ???

 

A league system that lets you qualify when you lose more games than you win is definitely flawed.

Posted

Should just be straight knock out, so should the European cup get rid of the dross like liverpool early on instead of giving opertunitys to teams who arnt good enough and dont deserve to be there.

 

 

Posted

Should just be straight knock out, so should the European cup get rid of the dross like liverpool early on instead of giving opertunitys to teams who arnt good enough and dont deserve to be there.

 

 

 

I dont mind the Champions League, but it should be champions only, and I can hardly remember when Liverpool last won the league, although it would be quite refreshing if they did.  :thumbsup:

Posted

Its part of the argument. If you can go through when you only win 1 game, lose 2 and draw 1 then its clear that the systems got problems, which is how we managed to get through.

 

Of course its a different argument. You said we didnt deserve to get through which in my opinion is wrong. All the teams knew before it started how you qualified for the next round. We qualified, Moscow and Copenhagen didnt. Thats because we deserved to qualify from that group.

 

The UEFA cup and the Champions League have got ridiculous because its all about making money for the rich clubs. A new format is definitely required.

Posted

1 win in 8 games in the whole tournament says otherwise. We benefited from a stupid set-up, thats all.

 

We qualified from the set up that exists.

 

What do you want AFC to do? Qualify from a series of imaginary set ups that satisfy your idea of fairness that allows only "deserving" teams to progress?

 

To my mind the set up actually allows teams like ours that opportunity to get a wee taste of the big stuff.

 

Same as finishing 4th in the league. Dafties suggest we didn't deserve it. We did. We got the necessary points. Same as Europe.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...