Disciplinary record

[tom_widdows]

Seems we have hit a run of finishing each game with at least 1 player sent off. Is it a case of a new harder edge to the squad?

 

Aberdeen - 2008/2009 5 red cards  (1 every 7.6 games) (Joint 3rd worst)

                              58 Yellow cards (1.53 per match) (9th worst in SPL)

 

                2009/2010 5 Red Cards (1 every 2.8 games) (3rd worst in SPL)

                              29 Yellow cards (2.07 per match) (joint worst in SPL with Hibs)

 

or is it the case that referees are getting too card happy?

 

SPL totals

2008/2009 38 rounds of matches - 54 red Cards (1.4 red cards each round)

                                              752 Yellow Cards (19 yellow cards each round)

2009/2010  14 rounds of matches - 29 Red Cards (2.07 per round) (12 in the last 3 weeks)

                                                291 yellow cards (20.8 yellow cards each round)

                                              (arabs vs huns still to be played too)

 

Perhaps a new prediction league should be set up for 'whos going to be sent off this week?'

[El Padre™]

I honestly think ref's are trying to make some sort of point as a lot of the bookings this season (not just for us) have been utterly ludicrous. They're also getting far too much protection with this ban on criticism. Players, coaches, managers right up the club chairmen can all be lambasted publicly for their failings, so why not the referees? They have to be publicly called into question for their shambolic performances this season.

[Kowalski]

Huge Dallas was our last decent ref, but he's now supposed to be in charge of the current lot, and is making a James Hunt of it.

 

In saying that, Ifil was an eejit yesterday.

[glasgowdon]

Was it not this point last season where refs came out saying they wanted to be salaried for their "profession"?

 

[wee toon red]

I think a lot of it has to do with so many relatively young and inexperienced (you could take that as a euphimism for shite) referees are working in the SPL these days. They seem to referee by the letter of the law and don't seem willing or able to use common sense.

[jmo]

Looking at red cards this season for Aberdeen and other teams in the SPL it seems to me that refs are getting increasingly card happy.

 

 

There are yellow cards often given in the SPL for challenges that in England for example are only free kicks.

[Reekie_Red]

Looking at red cards this season for Aberdeen and other teams in the SPL it seems to me that refs are getting increasingly card happy.

 

There are yellow cards often given in the SPL for challenges that in England for example are only free kicks.

 

Completely agree here. Whilst Ifil's red card vs Celtic was totally deserved, the second yellow for Kerr vs Rangers was NEVER a bookable offense. It was a standard tackle that could've been successful, had no malice in it, and did not stop a certain goal from occurring ... why then did he get booked? Is there no official appeal process we can go through to challenge the SFA refs' decisions?

[tom_widdows]

Arabs must be more pissed off than us. They only has 2 reds last season. They've already had 6 and its not even january

[El Padre™]

Arabs must be more pissed off than us. They only has 2 reds last season. They've already had 6 and its not even january

 

This is my point, somethings amiss here and it needs to be looked into before it gets further out of hand.

[Jute]

Completely agree here. Whilst Ifil's red card vs Celtic was totally deserved, the second yellow for Kerr vs Rangers was NEVER a bookable offense. It was a standard tackle that could've been successful, had no malice in it, and did not stop a certain goal from occurring ... why then did he get booked? Is there no official appeal process we can go through to challenge the SFA refs' decisions?

 

Can only appeal red cards. Yellows cannot be appealed unless you are claiming mistaken identity.

[Reekie_Red]

Can you appeal second-yellows? Or is it only straight reds you can appeal?

[dave_min]

Can you appeal second-yellows? Or is it only straight reds you can appeal?

 

Yellows cannot be appealed unless you are claiming mistaken identity.

[BobbyBiscuit]

Huge Dallas was our last decent ref, but he's now supposed to be in charge of the current lot, and is making a James Hunt of it.

 

In saying that, Ifil was an eejit yesterday.

 

Dallas was an ok ref, but his problem was he wanted to be Scotland's answer to Collina and that in turn has led to a bigger problem for the game now as they all seem to have a "look at me" attitude when it comes to reffing, which Dallas certainly had in his last couple of seasons as a ref.  Until that attitude is dispensed of, we'll keep seeing yellows and reds dished out for the equivalent of fuck all.

[El Padre™]

There was a definite gulf between Dallas and what we have now, that much is blatantly obvious. That said, it's time to remove some of the protection that refs have and allow questions to be asked publicly. Peoples livelihoods are being damaged by their inability to perform.

[glasgowdon]

There was a definite gulf between Dallas and what we have now, that much is blatantly obvious. That said, it's time to remove some of the protection that refs have and allow questions to be asked publicly. Peoples livelihoods are being damaged by their inability to perform.

 

As someone mentioned before, if anyone else was in a job making that many mistakes, some sort of action would be taken.

[dave_min]

Well aye, but hopefully I get another job soon. 

 

Seriously though, I'm taking application forms for McDonalds to the next game I attend and I'll be handing them to the officials.

 

You better not.

 

They'll just end up with papercuts.

[El Padre™]

As someone mentioned before, if anyone else was in a job making that many mistakes, some sort of action would be taken.

 

Well aye, but hopefully I get another job soon. 

 

Seriously though, I'm taking application forms for McDonalds to the next game I attend and I'll be handing them to the officials.

[Stewart]

 

Dallas was an ok ref, but his problem was he wanted to be Scotland's answer to Collina and that in turn has led to a bigger problem for the game now as they all seem to have a "look at me" attitude when it comes to reffing, which Dallas certainly had in his last couple of seasons as a ref.  Until that attitude is dispensed of, we'll keep seeing yellows and reds dished out for the equivalent of fuck all.

 

Totally agree about the look at me attitude.

 

So many times there's been a free kick given and the ref feels the need to rush over before anything happens even when the players haven't shown a sign of having a go with each other.

[maverick sheep]

referee@scottishfa.co.uk

[Jute]

Record is likely to get worse on Saturday as we have been given Alan Muir as referee according to Daily Retard. He has sent off 5 players in his last two matches and all 4 managers of the teams involved has slated his performance.

[TENEMENTFUNSTER]

The refs this season have been an utter disgrace, throughout the league.

 

We've been on the wrong end of some astoundingly pish decisions, aside from Ifil's idiocy, but there is clearly something amiss with the manner in which refs are brandishing cards for ridiculous reasons. As much as it was fucking brilliant, the decision to send off Michael Stewart yesterday was the whole thing beautifully encapsulated, a nonsense decision.

 

I agree to an extent that refs seem to be having a "look at me look at me" episode but it's resulting in refs undermining what little authority and respect they had, that and folk now looking at them more than ever and saying "I've looked, yer a cunt". 

[glasgow sheep]

Every year you think you are watching the worst refereeing performance you have ever seen but year on year they top it.  Every club in the SPL will be fined for poor discipline at this rate.......maybe that's the plan.

 

Useful site for SPL refs.  Amazingly some haven't sent anybody off!  http://www.splrefs.com/All-Refs/All-Referees-Cards.php?TeamID=&TeamName=All+Refs&sort=RedAvg

 

EDIT: Bloody hell check Steve Conroy: 8 Games 45 Yellows and 4 Reds!

[dave_min]

Pretty decent idea from McGhee imo:

 

Mark McGhee - time out for indisiplined players 11.12.2009

 

Dons take innovative approach to on field sinners

 

In response to the disciplinary record this season, and to demonstrate the clubs acceptance of the players and managements role in maintaining a high level of discipline on the field, Aberdeen manager Mark McGhee has introduced a new system of punishment at Pittodrie.

 

Mark McGhee said: "As a manager I have never operated a system of fiscal punishment. I do however believe that we have to support the authorities in cleaning up our game and improving discipline on the field of play.

 

"I've never been a manager who felt it was fair to fine players money. I don't think we have any right to do that. I felt we had to come up with something that is strong on the players, but also gives a little something back as well.

 

"With this objective in mind I have introduced a system of fines based on the players own private time. It has the full backing of the players. The system will be a 'Work in the Community' exercise which will require the players to participate where required in projects in the greater community.

 

"I don't want people to misunderstand what I'm saying. We're not about to send players out to dig up roads and sweep the streets, but players will be asked to give up an increasing amount of their own time - based on a first caution, red card, first suspension, second suspension and so on.

 

"I've spoken to our 'Dons in the Community' department as well as our commercial team who are in touch with the police and other organisations throughout the city.

 

"If there's a situation where, for instance, they have something on (like a coaching session or a seminar) and they think one of our players could help them then the player who's had a red or yellow card will go along.

 

"We don't want suspensions as has been the case on five or six separate occasions already this season. So we've decided to try to put down a strong message to show we're supporting the authorities.

 

"I feel strongly that it's a two way street, obviously the authorities have a responsibility to the referee, but we as clubs have a responsibility to make sure our players are doing everything they can to play within the laws of the game.

 

"It won't be retrospective punishment. It will come in to force for tomorrow's game with Hamilton.

 

"It's important to remember that this is extra work on top of what they already do for the Community and Commercial departments at the club. There are many different player appearances organised by marketing team each week."

[Guest ally s]

 

It's not a totally new concept but one which should be applauded nonetheless.

 

Well done McGhee

[dave_min]

Where is that from dave?

 

You would think they would have spelt indisciplined correctly.

 

Offishal site.