mizer Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Revised down to 10 from last Months poll
mizer Posted December 1, 2010 Author Report Posted December 1, 2010 Yes I would rather have that manger rather than McGoo
bloo_toon_red Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Speaking of JC, with the 4th most votes in the previous poll, why no Jimmy Calderwood? It's no more unrealistic than Curbishley or Burley...
Harcus Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Gordon Strachan - too dear, would he want to work with no budget? Jocky Scott - could be an option, bags of experience, question of not having managed at top-level recently? Alan Curbishley - too dear Paul Hartley - not that terrible a plan IMO. However, a rookie would be a massive risk given we're in a relegation battle. George Burley - seems to be doing OK at Palace? therefore unrealistic. Darren Ferguson - can't imagine we'd be very attractive prospect for him. May be unemployed soon though Billy Stark - good record with youngsters, but has failed at club level in past. Craig Brown - wouldn't want to leave Motherwell for us IMO, and why would he? Compensation issues. Derek McInnes - see compensation issues. St Johnstone have nearly been as bad as us this season. Again, are we an atractive prospect for anyone employed in the SPL? Eric Black - too dear to buy out contract perhaps? Would he want to give up a good job to come to a risky one? A name that seems to have been dropped is John McGlynn. Worth a closer look I think.
Kowalski Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Not that I'd necessarily vote for him, but Butcher is said to be good friends with Willie Miller. I don't see how he can be ruled out. Voted Curbishley but suspect he's not a realistic option.
baggy89 Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 If those were the actual choices I'd stick with the guy I thought should have been brought in when Calderwood was punted, even if it would cost (even) more money and regardless of him being an ex-jute and ex-hun. McInnes. At the same time any one of those would be acceptable as far as I am concerned.
mizer Posted December 1, 2010 Author Report Posted December 1, 2010 Not that I'd necessarily vote for him, but Butcher is said to be good friends with Willie Miller. I don't see how he can be ruled out. he wasnt voted enough for the first time
Harcus Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Further to McGlynn, he's taken Raith from the Second Division to the top of the first, via a Scottish Cup semi-final last season. Has also had spells as caretaker of Hearts. We could do a lot worse.
dunblanedon Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 I'm tempted to say bring back JC. If that's too obvious, Terry Butcher might be another name on the radar.
Jute Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Would love Curbishley but think Billy Stark is more practical option.
dickofthedons Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Next Manager Poll MkII We are all still in shock how bad Mark one was, dont think I want a MkII
Kowalski Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Alan Pardew anyone? Just throwing it out there....
TENEMENTFUNSTER Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 I'm tempted to say bring back JC. If that's too obvious, Terry Butcher might be another name on the radar. Why not? John McGlynn isn't a wild shout either. Neither is JC though.
Sandaldinho Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 McGlynn or McInnes i'd say both are realistic targets
Kowalski Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/teams/a/aberdeen/9248781.stm Terry Butcher, who has led Inverness Caledonian Thistle to promotion and who now lie fourth in the SPL, has emerged as an early favourite. Former Aberdeen midfielder Gordon Strachan, unemployed after leaving Middlesbrough, and Jimmy Calderwood, who was McGhee's predecessor at Pittodrie, are also possible candidates.
BobbyBiscuit Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Alan Pardew anyone? Just throwing it out there.... Drives a Lambourghini (sp?) because he couldn't afford one as a player, lost his last two jobs because he was shagging girlfriends/wives of his own players. We've got enough fannies at Pittodrie without a fanny in a mid life crisis leading the rest of the fannies. So, that's a no from me...
Kowalski Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Drives a Lambourghini (sp?) because he couldn't afford one as a player, lost his last two jobs because he was shagging girlfriends/wives of his own players. We've got enough fannies at Pittodrie without a fanny in a mid life crisis leading the rest of the fannies. So, that's a no from me... Fair enough, I hadn't heard any of that. Just trying to think something out of left field. I see Curbishley's on Sky Sports 1 just now. His phone hasn't rung yet...
BobbyBiscuit Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Fair enough, I hadn't heard any of that. Just trying to think something out of left field. I see Curbishley's on Sky Sports 1 just now. His phone hasn't rung yet... Wasn't having a go at you Kow, he is actually a decent manager but not sure he's what our youngsters should be looking up to.
Kowalski Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 Wasn't having a go at you Kow, he is actually a decent manager but not sure he's what our youngsters should be looking up to. Sounds like a decent point to me!
Kowalski Posted December 1, 2010 Report Posted December 1, 2010 http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2010/dec/01/mark-mcghee-sacked-aberdeen The former Hibernian manager John Hughes will be linked with the vacancy as will Paul Hartley, the club captain. Hartley may work in partnership with the Raith Rovers manager John McGlynn.
Recommended Posts