Holyjoe Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Going by what RedTV have said, Hamilton have been slightly the better team and they reckon they will feel aggrieved not to go in ahead. Quote
Edinburghdon Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 The BBC commentary is quality! "I suspect Jimmy Calderwood will be giving his players a roasting at half time" "Roasting but not in the sense usually associated with top class footballers" :lolabove: Quote
TENEMENTFUNSTER Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 The BBC commentary is quality! "I suspect Jimmy Calderwood will be giving his players a roasting at half time" "Roasting but not in the sense usually associated with top class footballers" :lolabove: Sounds like he needs to put something up their arses. Quote
glasgow sheep Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 6441. Oops. really ooops indeed bloody part timers Quote
Mackie's ace! Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Kilmarnock 1 Celtic 5 Date : Sat 02 Feb 2008 Kick Off : 12:00 Venue : Rugby Park Attendance : 6491 Comp : Scottish Cup Referee : Iain Brines Only 50 more at Rugby Park for an all SPL game. Quote
TENEMENTFUNSTER Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Duff off Maybury on. Zander!! Quote
TENEMENTFUNSTER Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 really ooops indeed bloody part timers Pretty much expected surely to fuck?! There are what? 200 hamilton fans there? Quote
glasgow sheep Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Pretty much expected surely to fuck?! There are what? 200 hamilton fans there? we never had such small crowds when we were shit(er) Quote
Slim Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Josh Walker was excellent, everyone else was shocking, especially Lee Miller. Quote
minijc Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Josh Walker was excellent, everyone else was shocking, especially Lee Miller. Walker looks really good especially for his age, really glad we got him in and he really deserved a goal today aswell, only made 5 mistakes the whole game and also looked very hungry and eager to do well. Thought miller wasna that great but maybe saving himself for tuesday or maybe not 100% match fit? Quote
TENEMENTFUNSTER Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Walker looks really good especially for his age, really glad we got him in and he really deserved a goal today aswell, only made 5 mistakes the whole game and also looked very hungry and eager to do well. Thought miller wasna that great but maybe saving himself for tuesday or maybe not 100% match fit? He's very well thought of down there. Good signing! Quote
BigAl Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Josh Walker was excellent, everyone else was shocking, especially Lee Miller. Nae wishing to be overly defensive of Miller, but given some of his performances of late, I guess we can let him off with the odd poor performance Quote
glasgow sheep Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Josh Walker was excellent, everyone else was shocking, especially Lee Miller. so he'll be dropped for tuesday then? Quote
Reekie_Red Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Walker's ineligible to play on Tuesday anyway. He wasn't a Dons player when the original match was supposed to go ahead. This is the very reason Brechin got dumped out of the Scottish Cup. Quote
Guest dundee_red Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Walker's ineligible to play on Tuesday anyway. He wasn't a Dons player when the original match was supposed to go ahead. This is the very reason Brechin got dumped out of the Scottish Cup. Did we not sign him the day of the game and have him in the squad for the original game? And does that rule not only apply for the Scottish Cup? Quote
Mackie's ace! Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Did we not sign him the day of the game and have him in the squad for the original game? And does that rule not only apply for the Scottish Cup? Yeah he was in squad for original game so must be. Maybury will be ineligible though? Quote
Mackie's ace! Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Eligibility of Players 8. Players taking part in the Competition must be registered in terms of Scottish Football League Rules or Scottish Premier League Rules as appropriate. 8.1 No Club shall play, or list as a named substitute, any player who, in the same season, has already played or been a named substitute for another Club, in the Competition. 8.2 It shall be the responsibility of each Club participating in the Competition to ensure that its players are eligible to play in any League Cup match. If a player participates in a League Cup match, such player being ineligible to play in the Cup match as a result of his suspension by The Scottish Football Association or for any other reason, the Club for which the player participates in the League Cup match shall be liable to such penalty as the Management Committee may decide. 8.3 Any Club infringing this Rule may be disqualified from the Competition and the tie awarded to its opponent. Quote
minijc Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Yeah he was in squad for original game so must be. Maybury will be ineligible though? Nah he is ok to play, the rules are different between the CIS cup and the Scottish cup, thankfully he will play and no duff or mair on the right. Quote
Monkey Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Walker played a stormer today but clearly is a defensive midfielder as got a nose bleed every time he got near Hamilton's 18 yard box, despite this, still a stand out player and a real coup in landing him. Oh and Duff is still shocking. Quote
Ajja Posted February 2, 2008 Report Posted February 2, 2008 Josh Walker was excellent, everyone else was shocking, especially Lee Miller. Sounded on the radio like Langfield saved our asses on several occasions. Was he shocking ? Quote
Slim Posted February 3, 2008 Report Posted February 3, 2008 No, Langfield was good, didn't even fuck up any kicks, my comments were more directed at the outfield players. Quote
Millers Tache Posted February 3, 2008 Report Posted February 3, 2008 Josh Walker was excellent, everyone else was shocking, especially Lee Miller. Personally, i'd have had Seve, Barry, JDV, Mackie and Duff ahead of Miller in the shite stakes yesterday. However, Miller seemed to have himself hell bent on getting sent off. Some of his challenges were shocking. The one he got booked for we thought he could have seen red, he blatantly swung a punch at one defender and could have given away numerous penalties at set pieces with his downright amateurish holding of players in the box. Mackie hasn't improved since he got injured and his second touch was (as usual) a tackle - and generally a late one - more often than not. Lovell at least put in the effort when he got on, but suffered (as usual) from our desparate long ball hoofing. Seve's too slow and ponderous. He's not the player he thinks he is and needs to concentrate on finding a player with a simple pass and keeping possession, rather than his usual two moves: a chipped/hoofed ball up to Miller, bypassing the midfield completely or taking it for a walk through midfield, losing it and blaming everyone around him for not asking for passes, when he had no intention of giving it to them anyway. When we signed Duff, Jimmy said he was not a good defender. Debut, in midfield, he gives away a goal. Second game, into defence he goes. Why Jimmy? Why would you do that to someone who needs to build his confidence if he is to have any hope in winning over the fans...? Barry was apparently carrying an injury and was a doubt right up to kick off, so i'll probably let him off with his performance. JDV was pish though. I really like him and think he's got everything he needs (except pace) to be a big success, but he just plain didn't fancy it yesterday, and that's not good enough. Still, at the end of the day, we didn't slip up and got into the hat for the next round. That's the main thing. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.