Jute Posted January 9, 2018 Report Posted January 9, 2018 Could not understand the Tansey signing in the first place as never really impressed by him so happy to see him go. At least we never paid a fee for him. Hopefully this means we have another central midfield player coming in as would not want to rely on Ball and O'Connor as back up there. Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 9, 2018 Report Posted January 9, 2018 Hopefully this means we have another central midfield player coming in as would not want to rely on Ball and O'Connor as back up there. To be honest, I wouldn't even want to rely on Shinnie and McLean as the number one option for the remainder of the season. There are games where it will be very beneficial to have Shinnie at left back. Quote
LA-Don Posted January 9, 2018 Author Report Posted January 9, 2018 To be honest, I wouldn't even want to rely on Shinnie and McLean as the number one option for the remainder of the season. There are games where it will be very beneficial to have Shinnie at left back. I honestly don't know if we need Shinnie at left back given the level of opposition. You could argue against Celtic perhaps but he's really needed in midfield for that game. Considine is limited but can contain the rest of our opponents for the most part, but we should be attacking all opponents and not relying on Shinnie at left back anyway. He's needed in midfield for the type of league we're in, in my opinion. Long term, I'd much rather we signed a new left back than move Shinnie back there. I think he gives us real drive, passion, and leadership from the middle of the park. Quote
Nips_and_Tatties Posted January 9, 2018 Report Posted January 9, 2018 Its easier said than done i suppose but i just never understand why we cant search further afield for talent. There are leagues all over the world so why do we always go for our own pish as mentioned above or irish players. All mediocre really. Ill stick my neck out and say we need to sack our scout/s and bring in people with far more vision OR DM needs to do more research. I mean thats his job right...creating a winning team? Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 9, 2018 Report Posted January 9, 2018 Its easier said than done i suppose but i just never understand why we cant search further afield for talent. There are leagues all over the world so why do we always go for our own pish as mentioned above or irish players. All mediocre really. Ill stick my neck out and say we need to sack our scout/s and bring in people with far more vision OR DM needs to do more research. I mean thats his job right...creating a winning team? The scouts are located in particular countries. Sacking a scout for not spotting talent in a country he doesn't work in seems a little harsh! We search in our own country, because that's where the best return happens. Shinnie, Flood, Robson, Rooney, Hayes, McGinn, McLean, Christie, Stewart, GMS etc were all proven SPL players and that's where you get the most success. Logan and Lewis are two of many more brought in fae down South with no SPL experience that have generally either been terrible or gone home after a decent loan spell. We pay much more than our rivals in the SPL, which means we can cream off some of the best players (less so now with der hun, hibs and edinburgh hun taking a share too) and that is by far the best way to get proven value for money and far less risky. We're struggling to find any stand outs at the moment, hence the Tansey/Storey errors. There are very few foreigners coming directly from abroad into the SPL these days, and certainly none that are a good example of why it would be a good idea for us. Can you name one in recent seasons that's come into the SPL from abroad that the dons have perhaps missed out on? Long gone are the days where we pay miles more than the other (good) leagues in Europe. A few years ago we were picking up amateurs fae the Dutch third division. The English lower leagues have so many players, it makes total sense to scout down there just in terms of sheer numbers of games that can be taken in within close proximity and available talent. A scout can only be in one place, so where would you suggest as a country? How would you compare that league's style and ability to our own (that actually seems a problem between Scotland and England, where players are good in the SPL but shite down South and vice versa - which suggests a lack of compatibility)? Quote
Nips_and_Tatties Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Was interested to hear ur views rico. However, because I couldnt tell you any foreign players available doesnt mean there arent. I would argue that many countries abroad have far better training facilities than Scotland. If I were a scout Id certainly be able to find a few ill guarantee you that much. Quote
ayrshire_don74 Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 think its a fair comment, how is/are our scouts by the way ? Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 However, because I couldnt tell you any foreign players available doesnt mean there arent. I would argue that many countries abroad have far better training facilities than Scotland. Apologies, I didn't mean name an individual player, I meant name a team that had successfully adopted a strategy of taking foreigners into the SPL. I can't think of anyone. The point about scouts is that you have to pay them, so they have to reside in the one country (generally speaking) so you have to decide on that country. We simply can't afford to have a reem of scouts in every country in the world so we have to be specific. You could be right about training facilities, but you have to remember that we're not comparing AFC v Everton or some such, we're comparing AFC/SPL v Tranmere or Spanish/Dutch/German second or third tier so the additional gains in terms of facilities probably aren't there at the level we're shopping in. Perhaps Scandinavia might offer us something in that regard, but the level of player over there doesn't seem to eclipse what we have either. Finally, you think Maynard is good, so I'm not sure you can be trusted to scout for the dons! Quote
Reidzer 1314 Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Chidi Nwakali had joined from Man City on loan until the end of the season subject to work permit. Central Midfielder. He is with the squad in Dubai. Quote
Tyrant Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Chidi Nwakali had joined from Man City on loan until the end of the season subject to work permit. Central Midfielder. He is with the squad in Dubai. Got to be better than Tansey with a name like that. Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Yasssssss. Do you reckon they've edited his passport to say "Greg Tansey" to save on flight costs? Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 I did wonder when they let Tansey go, how long it wid be before we signed someone. It's very unlike Deek not to have a player sorted before letting one go. I'm assuming it's the only reason Maynard is still hanging around. Quote
BigAl Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Can't say I know anything about this lad, nonetheless welcome on board the good ship AFC. Lets hope he turms out to be more Maddison than Parker/Daniels Quote
Nips_and_Tatties Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Haha rico Maynard oozes class.you'll all see. WHOAHAHAHAAAAAAAAA.(evil laugh). Chidi Nwakali sounds like a foreign digestive disease. The name itself is fine by me. And the Mohammed ali song is perfect for him. "Nwakali......Nwakaaaaaali He flew up from Manchester To be a Dandyyyy" Quote
Nips_and_Tatties Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Looks superb. That was some fucking pass back. Quote
BigAl Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Looks superb. Fucking hell that was some strike. Lose the gloves though son afore you pull on the Red shirt. Quote
Elgindon Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Haha rico Maynard oozes class.you'll all see. WHOAHAHAHAAAAAAAAA.(evil laugh). Chidi Nwakali sounds like a foreign digestive disease. The name itself is fine by me. And the Mohammed ali song is perfect for him. "Nwakali......Nwakaaaaaali He flew up from Manchester To be a Dandyyyy" Needs a bit of work,how about 'Nwakali.....Chidi Nwakali' etc Either way,he scored a goal once,so I'm in Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 A 20 second video, where only the first 6 seconds are devoted to the goal; the rest some celebration and ads. Disgusting. Also, there are two sounds when he kicks the ball, which suggests to me that it bounced off his shin and then his foot, making it a fluke. Send him back, he's pish. Did Maynard not score an ace goal in some youtube clip once? Quote
BigAl Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 A 20 second video, where only the first 6 seconds are devoted to the goal; the rest some celebration and ads. Disgusting. Also, there are two sounds when he kicks the ball, which suggests to me that it bounced off his shin and then his foot, making it a fluke. Send him back, he's pish. Did Maynard not score an ace goal in some youtube clip once? Quote
Nips_and_Tatties Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Thats ma boyyyy Get him signed up. Quote
BigAl Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Thats ma boyyyy Get him signed up. The words "dead horse" spring to mind N&T Quote
Nips_and_Tatties Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 This is akin to that dude not signing the Beatles up because he didnt think they were that good. Regretted it for the rest of his life. Quote
BigAl Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 This is akin to that dude not signing the Beatles up because he didnt think they were that good. Regretted it for the rest of his life. Fecking hell min, that is some comparison Quote
BigAl Posted January 10, 2018 Report Posted January 10, 2018 Why is there nothing on the official site about this loan signing ? Seems a little bizarre that it's all over the press but we haven't confirmed it on our own site Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.