OrlandoDon Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 Can’t we just hire donstalk as next manager? We’ll clearly do a great job and have all the answers. Rico as spokesman though, we’ll need a fall guy. 1 Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 31 Author Report Posted January 31 8 minutes ago, OrlandoDon said: Can’t we just hire donstalk as next manager? We’ll clearly do a great job and have all the answers. Rico as spokesman though, we’ll need a fall guy. Would I get to keep my seat in the RDL for when it goes tits up? If so, I'm in. In all seriousness, you could imagine Cormack giving a fan the job after an altercation on Twitter, where he challenges some minker to see if they could do a better job. Quote
Slim Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 Craig Samson still here? I have an irrational annoyance of seeing him on the touchline interfering with tactics, subs, etc. Quote
Stewart Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 P&J reckon they've already sounded out Warnock. Would be a disaster I think. 1 Quote
Slim Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 Fucking fuck me, Colin Wanker would be a disaster. Quote
baggy89 Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 76 year old Neil Warnock? Talk about long term succession planning... Quote
tlg1903 Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 I would be fucking furious if it's a dinosaur like warnock 2bh Quote
dons8321 Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 5 minutes ago, tlg1903 said: I would be fucking furious if it's a dinosaur like warnock 2bh How about a sprightly young 69 y/o...Sam Allardyce Quote
Kowalski Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 Warnock spotted at the airport half an hour ago. Quote
Jute Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 If it’s Warnock I will be staying away until he is gone. Dinosaur whose teams usually play route one football and had a couple of top flight stints in England where his team were relegated. Surely to fuck we have better options. 1 Quote
Panda Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 Warnock isn't a surprise, because the FMB are more likely to be impressed by a 76-year-old Neil Warnock than they are with a young manager who has been doing the business in Scandinavia. Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 31 Author Report Posted January 31 This sounds like a story released to the P&J by a Mr Warnock, from England. It fucking better be. 1 Quote
Kowalski Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 I think we need to start thinking about who would realistically come to Aberdeen. How about Klopp? Or Xavi (player / coach)? Quote
tlg1903 Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 Hopefully that's just from people betting on warnock Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 31 Author Report Posted January 31 1 minute ago, Jute said: Where did they find these lunatics. I saw thon first lad at the fitba last night. Actually held the door open for him as I was leaving the chunty and he was going in. Would have belted it off his coupon if he'd suggested Lennon to me. I'd rather have yogi. At least it'd be funny. 3 Quote
Kowalski Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 Odds have rapidly shortened on Neil Lennon! Quote
DantheDon Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 I don’t have much to contribute regards who should come in. But I thought an interesting stat (that I’m pretty certain is correct) is that Robson won the same amount of league games as interim manager as he did when he got the job permanently. That number is seven games. Have to admit although I didn’t expect the good form to continue indefinitely, I didn’t see the drop off in results that occurred happening. It’s almost hard to be critical of the board when you look at it that way. Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 31 Author Report Posted January 31 (edited) 23 minutes ago, DantheDon said: I don’t have much to contribute regards who should come in. But I thought an interesting stat (that I’m pretty certain is correct) is that Robson won the same amount of league games as interim manager as he did when he got the job permanently. That number is seven games. Have to admit although I didn’t expect the good form to continue indefinitely, I didn’t see the drop off in results that occurred happening. It’s almost hard to be critical of the board when you look at it that way. The board got in an inexperienced manager for our heaviest scheduled season this century and didn't get anyone with experience above him, all after the two previous inexperienced guys failed in similar circumstances. It's entirely their fault. If Robson had succeeded, it would have been pure luck. Obviously, you can always pick up a bad manager, or one who just doesn't fit for whatever reason, but you have to mitigate that in any way possible. Suffice to say, it's clear that there's nobody at the club capable of holding a manager to account and so any good appointment we might make will be down to luck. Edited January 31 by RicoS321 1 Quote
DantheDon Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 6 minutes ago, RicoS321 said: The board got in an inexperienced manager for our heaviest scheduled season this century and didn't get anyone with experience above him, all after the two previous inexperienced guys failed in similar circumstances. It's entirely their fault. If Robson had succeeded, it would have been pure luck. Obviously, you can always pick up a bad manager, or one who just doesn't fit for whatever reason, but you have to mitigate that in any way possible. Suffice to say, it's clear that there's nobody at the club capable of holding a manager to account and so any good appointment we might make will be down to luck. I think you’re right that someone more experienced should have been operating above him. But I also wonder if that would have made all that much difference as it seems to be tactically that he was struggling and if you take that aspect away from the coach he’s not really the coach. My point was more along the lines of you can’t blame them for the appointment. I remember when he got the job there was a bewilderment that it took the board so long to give it to him on the back of the results he was getting. Quote
RicoS321 Posted January 31 Author Report Posted January 31 9 minutes ago, DantheDon said: I think you’re right that someone more experienced should have been operating above him. But I also wonder if that would have made all that much difference as it seems to be tactically that he was struggling and if you take that aspect away from the coach he’s not really the coach. My point was more along the lines of you can’t blame them for the appointment. I remember when he got the job there was a bewilderment that it took the board so long to give it to him on the back of the results he was getting. Aye, I know what you mean. His form didn't really leave them with much choice. You don't need to take tactics away from the manager, you just need to play devil's advocate and challenge those tactics and get him to explain himself. The idea being that he questions himself and what he's doing, which is vital for a young manager, to avoid the sort of cognitive dissonance that effected Glass, Goodwin and Robson. All three went through long periods of making the same mistake over and over, with apparently nobody to hold them to account or make them questions themselves. It was like they were paralysed, and just couldn't see that what they were doing was wrong. It just needs consistent messaging and questioning: "Barry, your setting us up to play with Ramadani despite the fact Ylber left in the summer, and none of the replacements are in any way similar to him. Explain that to me as a layman". It's not about taking responsibility from him, rather about shaking him out of a rut when there's a prolonged period of poor results from making the same mistakes. He'd still get to set up as he saw fit, nobody could tell him that three at the back wasn't allowed or anything like that. Robson himself said that he needed someone at the club who would challenge him, and I don't think that ever happened (or if it did, they weren't actually challenging him). Quote
Panda Posted January 31 Report Posted January 31 2 hours ago, Jute said: Where did they find these lunatics? Technically, they found them at Pittodrie... Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.