Jump to content

Saturday 23rd November 2024 - kick-off 3pm

Scottish Premiership - St Mirren v Aberdeen

Celtic v Aberdeen


Panda

Recommended Posts

Didn’t see the game so can’t comment. My knee jerk reaction is to punt Robson too and just start afresh with a whole new coaching staff. Get some guy in (not strachan) who is experienced but not SPL tarnished. Someone like an Ange for example. Not easy to find but a fresh new face may be a good thing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We looked a really poor team today. Alarmingly poor.

The way we constantly coughed up possession either from poor passes or being brushed off the ball was unforgivable. Rarely, if ever, did we actually put together a good passage of play, I'm struggling to think of one. The goals were soft, and we offered nothing at the other end except the two times Joe Hart nae two errors. We cannot cross the ball, no-one can beat their man. It's all so basic and shows just how badly they've been coached all season.

Tactically the three at the back gave Celtic too much space in the first half although we did at least change the shape, even if by the time we did the horse had bolted, spent the day at the pub, and strolled back with a couple of fillies and stuck a do not disturb sign on the stable door.

But I don't think there's a huge amount of criticism you can really give Robson for the 90 minutes. The mistakes from individuals weren't on him, and he had named pretty much the line-up you expected him to. But we didn't look fit (that's not on him), we looked slow (not on him). He picked Hayes because he thought he would offer more defensively and was rewarded by a really poor performance in return. 

Ramadani, lots of enthusiasm, but he's not Aberdeen standard I don't think. Shinnie was trying to run that midfield himself. Duk far too slow and ponderous. Clarkson really poor although at least he was always looking for the ball.

To be fair to Robson, he corrected most of these mistakes as the game went on although he took too long to do them. At least he got there eventually, which is more than could be said for Goodwin.

I don't see a new manager coming in before Livingston so it's a huge seven days for Robson. He has to identify the weaknesses, he has to make changes for Livingston, and by fuck do we need to win that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tim mate, who was at the game and a very level headed kinda guy, said that was one of our worst performances there in some time. Offered nothing and if we don’t get our manager right, we should be worried. Which we all know. But I found it quite disturbing that other fans know this too. 
 

wont be watching the lowlights, onwards to a much more important game against livi. Hope we have our shit together by then.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The most annoying thing about this is not the result (I expected worse tbh), not the performance (our squad confidence is as fragile as Paul Bernard's leg)

its the amount of huns plaguing the official AFC social media posts with this new "4 games a season club" shite. I swear this has suddenly appeared just recently but I've spotted so many different huns saying this. I don't know if it annoys me, or if it gives me a wee bit of pleasure knowing that their own paranoia and Dons-obsession is getting under their own skin. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 19/02/2023 at 03:03, manc_don said:

 wont be watching the lowlights, onwards to a much more important game against livi. Hope we have our shit together by then.

^^^^

This

I have Sportscene on series link to record. Deleted this weekend's without watching any of it

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This might be the best Celtic team I've seen. The speed, consistency and intensity of their press is frightening. So I don't like the negative hyperbole I've seen on social media regarding our performance. Confidence is shot and I can kind of understand why. 

First half from us was awful, genuinely thought we might have beaten McGhee's record after 13 minutes. Every dons player panicked when the ball came near them, the decision making was horrendous and not one player was willing to take charge, all looking at one another. Gorter, almost single handedly kept it at 2-0 till half-time. Robson and Agnew got things more organised in the second half and we actually looked like we might be growing into the game. But the total lack of confidence still evident in things like Clarkson's "shot" from the rhs that went out for a throw on the lhs. Hayes not just lobbing Hart, instead laying it off to Ramadani only for Hart to make a save with his hands outside the box right in front of the ref.  One of your better players missing so horrendously and then being denied a freekick and a sending off.

That said nothing excuses the weak defending and numerous basic errors.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, baggy89 said:

One of your better players missing so horrendously and then being denied a freekick and a sending off.

I didn't watch the game, but just looked back at the highlights, and I don't think it was a handball (as per the rules). It definitely wasn't a red card either way, as the ball hits off his body and then onto his hand, so if it hadn't hit his hand it would have dropped fairly harmlessly to one of their covering players as the sting had already been taken out of the (exceptionally pish) shot. For me, it would have been a clear and obvious error if a red had been given, but not the other way around. I could understand a ref giving a foul in real time, and possibly even a red depending on how he'd interpreted it in real time. But the fact it hits his body first, for me, looks the right call.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

41 minutes ago, RicoS321 said:

I didn't watch the game, but just looked back at the highlights, and I don't think it was a handball (as per the rules). It definitely wasn't a red card either way, as the ball hits off his body and then onto his hand, so if it hadn't hit his hand it would have dropped fairly harmlessly to one of their covering players as the sting had already been taken out of the (exceptionally pish) shot. For me, it would have been a clear and obvious error if a red had been given, but not the other way around. I could understand a ref giving a foul in real time, and possibly even a red depending on how he'd interpreted it in real time. But the fact it hits his body first, for me, looks the right call.

Fair enough. There was no replay on RedTV. Looked like Ramadani hit it, Hart's arm came out and the ball changed direction. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

Apparently we have a game tomorrow. Not sure what’s worse, no thread on the go or me too lazy to start a new one.

anyway, no pressure game for us. Hope to see an attacking game like hibs and st mirren have done this last week with the tic. I’d love to see us start bavidge for the experience, why not? 
2-2, duk and bavidge.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't think the following will play

Miovski (obviously), Duk, McCrorie, Hayes.

Expect Watkins and Bavidge up front.

Interest factor pretty low to be honest

Will probably watch the play off for fourth place instead.

Let the season end and this summer's rebuild swing into action

P.S Manc is sacked for being too lazy to start a match thread 😉 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, BigAl said:

Don't think the following will play

Miovski (obviously), Duk, McCrorie, Hayes.

Expect Watkins and Bavidge up front.

Interest factor pretty low to be honest

Will probably watch the play off for fourth place instead.

Let the season end and this summer's rebuild swing into action

P.S Manc is sacked for being too lazy to start a match thread 😉 

Yeah I don't give a flying fuck how we get on at the San giro 2bh.  Absolutely agree with giving bavidge a start, let's see how kid handles it. The interesting game of the weekend for me is the Killie county game on Sunday as I would much prefer Killie to be put into the playoffs than RC. 2 reasons, fuck the plastic pitch and having top flight football in the highlands is so good for the region (I live in Inverness for those that don't know). 

I will be keeping an eye on the Edinburgh Derby though and massively rooting for the spoon burners. It would be so funny if hibs pipped them to 4th, my neighbour is a jambo and I would have a fucking field day with him. 

 

I suspect we will probably lose tomorrow, celtic will likely be back to full strength with the cup final approaching and I suspect our squad will be somewhat jaded after midweek celebrations.  

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, tlg1903 said:

Yeah I don't give a flying fuck how we get on at the San giro 2bh.  Absolutely agree with giving bavidge a start, let's see how kid handles it. The interesting game of the weekend for me is the Killie county game on Sunday as I would much prefer Killie to be put into the playoffs than RC. 2 reasons, fuck the plastic pitch and having top flight football in the highlands is so good for the region (I live in Inverness for those that don't know). 

I will be keeping an eye on the Edinburgh Derby though and massively rooting for the spoon burners. It would be so funny if hibs pipped them to 4th, my neighbour is a jambo and I would have a fucking field day with him. 

 

I suspect we will probably lose tomorrow, celtic will likely be back to full strength with the cup final approaching and I suspect our squad will be somewhat jaded after midweek celebrations.  

 

 

I am contemplating going to the Killie game on Sunday as just fifteen minutes door to door

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Unlike you cunts I will be there supporting the team because I a real fan and not because I am a pessimistic cunt who thought it would go to last game so bought a ticket. 
 

Would assume Robson will give run outs to fringe players and those that are leaving. This could end up any score as  Victims could easily rest a few players with cup final in mind. 
 

In

train then pub in town before last minute dash to ground

away end

pub then train back to capital. 
 

2-2 Bavidge and Clarkson

  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Jute said:

Unlike you cunts I will be there supporting the team because I a real fan and not because I am a pessimistic cunt who thought it would go to last game so bought a ticket. 
 

Would assume Robson will give run outs to fringe players and those that are leaving. This could end up any score as  Victims could easily rest a few players with cup final in mind. 
 

In

train then pub in town before last minute dash to ground

away end

pub then train back to capital. 
 

2-2 Bavidge and Clarkson

You're only predicting two each because it will win you the 2023-23 predictor league 😂

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why are people thinking we’ll field a weakened side???? Pretty sure Robson will want to beat Celtic, and the chance is there. Other than bavidge in for miovski, no reason to change. Don’t buy or support play kennedy for example cos he’s leaving…

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, OrlandoDon said:

Why are people thinking we’ll field a weakened side???? Pretty sure Robson will want to beat Celtic, and the chance is there. Other than bavidge in for miovski, no reason to change. Don’t buy or support play kennedy for example cos he’s leaving…

Only because it’s usually what happens in meaningless end of season games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, OrlandoDon said:

Don’t buy or support play kennedy for example cos he’s leaving…

What about: "play Kennedy because the other guy is about to net us £2M"?

Or: "play Kennedy because the other guy is about to net us £2M and, he isn't Jayden Richardson"?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...